Threshold and the Irish Council for International Students (ICOS) have cautioned that proposed changes to housing legislation could leave certain renters living in garden homes without protection of rental legislation or recourse to the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB).
The charities have raised concerns about the pace at which the legislation, the Housing and Residential Tenancies (Miscellaneous Provisions) Bill 2026, is progressing, warning that insufficient time for detailed scrutiny could result in important safeguards being overlooked. The charities outlined that it is difficult to see the need for such expediency given the real-life ramifications that these changes will have for a large number of vulnerable renters.
Threshold and ICOS previously recommended having a full review of licensees before moving forward with any plans to increase the number of rented garden homes. This ensures that the increased supply is suitable and secure with legal protections and measures in place for enforcement of housing standards for the occupants, particularly vulnerable renters such as older people and students.
Additionally, based on what has been announced by the Government to date, residents of these exempted developments would automatically be classified as licensees. In Ireland, licensees are occupants who do not have protections under the Residential Tenancies Acts and do not have recourse to the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB). Currently, people renting garden homes can avail of the protections under the Act. However, the action currently proposed by the Government will strip these renters of their rights.
Threshold and ICOS are calling for the new proposals to remove those renting garden homes from under the protection of the Residential Tenancies Acts to be fully examined before any changes are advanced. Without this important step, there will not be provisions for meaningful engagement with stakeholders to avoid any unintended consequences and impacts on vulnerable renters, housing quality and regulatory oversight.
Speaking on the issue, Threshold Advocacy Manager Ann-Marie O’Reilly said: “Threshold recognises the urgent need to increase housing supply, but new supply must not come at the expense of housing quality, tenant protections or proper oversight. New supply that leaves renters vulnerable to a next-day Notice to Quit – or a rent increase with no limit – is not the supply we should be providing.
“We remain concerned that progressing changes to exempted development regulations without sufficient scrutiny could result in more people living in inadequate, unsuitable, insecure accommodation. No one should lose basic housing protections simply because they are living in a garden home rather than a traditional rental property.
“In Threshold’s experience, people treated as licensees have limited security and few routes to recourse when problems arise. This is particularly concerning for students, including international students, older people and those already experiencing housing insecurity.
“These proposals need careful examination before any changes are advanced to ensure full consideration of the potential impact on tenants, housing quality and regulatory oversight.”
Orla Lehane, Executive Director of the Irish Council for International Students, said: “International students are already among the groups most vulnerable to insecure and informal housing arrangements. While efforts to increase housing supply are welcome, it is essential that new accommodation options are accompanied by clear safeguards, effective oversight and access to redress. We are calling on Government to take the time necessary to fully assess the potential consequences of these measures and to engage meaningfully with stakeholders before progressing any legislative changes. Housing supply and tenant protections must go hand in hand.”
Case Study: Melinda’s Story*
Melinda, an international student who came to Ireland to complete a Master’s degree at University College Cork, struggled to find accommodation and secured a garden cabin through an online rental platform. She paid €1,000 for the first month’s rent and €500 for the deposit.
Melinda said the accommodation had no heating and that the landlord often entered the cabin without notice. She also reported feeling uncomfortable due to ongoing disturbances by family members, questioning of why Melinda was at home rather than being on campus, and unreasonable requests from the landlord. Feeling increasingly unsafe, Melinda contacted the platform and was moved to alternative accommodation, but only after a stressful departure when she had to leave at night to avoid conflict.
Melinda has not recovered her deposit and believes she is unlikely to do so because she paid in cash and has limited documentation. Although the platform later banned the landlord, she has since seen the same property advertised elsewhere.
Reflecting on her experience, Melinda said she is concerned that other students and renters could find themselves in similar informal arrangements without adequate rights, protections or recourse when problems arise.